Pickle Fork vs Ball Joint Press: Which One Should You Buy?

GarageToolHQ earns a commission when you buy through links on our product pages, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Below: how a wedge tool and a press tool differ, when a wedge beats a press and when it does not, and the gear picks that cover the widest range of joint sizes.

Pickle fork vs ball joint press: where the difference comes from

A pickle fork works by wedging. The tapered fork slides between the joint and its seat, and hammer force on the handle drives the taper in until the stud pops free. The listings here describe that action for tie rod ends, ball joints and pitman arms, with fork openings from 21/32 inch to 1 2/3 inches across the four picks. A ball joint press works by pressing: a screw or ram pushes the joint straight out of its seat, and pushes a new joint back in. No pick here is a press, so the press side of this guide stays at the method level: pressing avoids wedging force, and wedging avoids the setup a press needs.

When a pickle fork is the right tool

Reach for a pickle fork when the job is separation alone for a part that is being replaced: a tie rod end, a ball joint or a pitman arm that must come off and will not be reused. The listings here cover cars and light vans, cars and light trucks, and FWD vehicles, with the ARES fork also stated for CV drive shafts on FWD vehicles. Fork opening is the first match to check: the opening must match the joint, and the sets below cover several openings in one case. A striking handle suits conventional hammers, while the DURATECH set adds an adapter handle for air hammer use.

When a press is the better choice

Reach for a press when the joint must go back in. A wedge separates by force, and it cannot press a new joint into its seat. A press also suits joints where wedging force could harm nearby parts, since it pushes straight instead of driving a wedge between the parts. The trade-off is setup: a press needs the right adapters and room to work, while a pickle fork needs only a hammer and room to swing. If the job is taper separation only, the wedge is faster to set up; if the job also includes pressing a joint out of or into its seat, that step needs a press, in addition to separation.

The gear for pickle fork vs ball joint press, ranked

The four gear picks below are all pickle forks, from the lifetime-warranty single fork to the two five-piece sets and the single tie rod fork. Each entry gives the fork openings, the build and the warranty term stated.

ARES 12016. A single 15/16 inch pickle fork, 11-7/8 inches long, built from tempered drop forged steel with a knurled handle for a steady grip. The listing states it separates ball joints and removes CV drive shafts on FWD vehicles, and it backs the tool with a Performance Assurance Limited Lifetime Warranty, the only lifetime term among these picks.

DURATECH 5-piece set. Three forks in 11/16, 15/16 and 1-1/8 inches, with a striking handle for conventional hammers and an adapter handle for air hammer use, all in a blow-molded case. The forks are forged and heat-treated from 40# steel with chrome-plated surfaces, and the knurled handles protect tool threads. No warranty term is stated.

Orion Motor Tech 5-piece set. Five fork open sizes: 3/4, 1, 1 2/3, 1 15/32 and 1 3/32 inches, for ball joints, tie rods and pitman arms on cars and trucks. The forks are single-piece solid construction from AISI 1045 medium carbon steel, heat-treated with a zinc coating, and the handles are knurled for grip. The listing mentions a strong warranty but states no concrete term, so no warranty term is counted here.

OEMTOOLS 25201. A single pickle fork with a 21/32 inch (16.7 mm) tapered opening, built from drop-forged, heat-treated steel with a zinc-plated finish and a long knurled handle. One wrinkle: the title and bullets state a 15-1/2 inch length while the spec table lists 18.6 inches in its dimensions. The title and bullets are used here. No warranty term is stated.

FAQ: garage tools

Can a pickle fork damage a ball joint?

The listings here present the wedge as a separation method, and the OEMTOOLS listing states its tapered fork removes tie rod ends without damaging surrounding components. A press, which pushes rather than wedges, is the alternative when wedging force is a concern. The OEMTOOLS claim is about surrounding components, not about the joint staying reusable, so do not read it as a promise that a forked joint can be reused.

What size pickle fork do I need?

Match the fork opening to the joint. The picks here range from a 21/32 inch opening to a 1 2/3 inch opening, and the sets cover several openings in one case: three forks in the DURATECH set and five in the Orion set. If the joint size is unknown, a set covers more sizes than a single fork.

Can I use a pickle fork with an air hammer?

The DURATECH set includes an adapter handle for air hammer use, alongside a striking handle for conventional hammers. The single forks here state hammer use: the ARES listing says to add extra force with a hammer as needed. No air hammer adapter is stated for the single forks.

Do pickle forks work on pitman arms?

Yes, on the listings here. The DURATECH set includes a pitman arm fork in 1-1/8 inches, and the Orion set lists pitman arms among its uses. The single forks here are stated for ball joints or tie rod ends, not pitman arms.

Which set covers the widest range of sizes?

The Orion set lists five fork open sizes, from 3/4 inch to 1 2/3 inches. The DURATECH set lists three fork sizes plus two handles, which covers fewer openings but adds air hammer use. A single fork covers one opening only.

Related: the ball joint press vs separator comparison, the ball joint press kit, the cordless impact wrench for suspension work, and our engine and shop equipment hub.