Stick Welder vs Multiprocess Welder: Which One Should You Buy?

GarageToolHQ earns a commission when you buy through links on our product pages, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.

Below: what each type does, how the machines in this guide compare, and how to match a machine to garage work.

The stick welder vs multiprocess welder question, answered

A stick welder, also called an MMA machine, strikes an arc between a flux-coated electrode and the work. The haxiaoer listing describes a 250A stick-only machine for 110V household supply, with hot start, adjustable arc force and anti-stick, and support for 1/16 inch to 1/8 inch electrodes such as E6013, E6011, E7018 and E308.

A multiprocess machine packs several processes into one box. The BILT HARD listing lists 6 functions: Gas MIG, Gasless Flux Core MIG, Spool Gun MIG, Lift TIG, Stick and Spot Welding, with up to 250A output and a 60% duty cycle at 250A, and it can weld up to a 3/8″ plate. The ARCCAPTAIN listing lists 8 welding modes, including Dual Pulse MIG, Single Pulse MIG, Gas MIG, Gasless Flux Core MIG, Stick Welding, Spot Welding, Lift TIG and Spool Gun MIG, with 205A output and 159 built-in parameter presets. The ANDELI listing adds a plasma cutter to the mix, with 205A max welding current and 50A max cutting current, plus Clean Cut 10mm (3/8″) and Maximum Cut 18mm (2/3″).

The gear: the machines ranked

The listings in this guide rank in this order, from the strongest overall listing to the simplest stick-only machine.

ARCCAPTAIN MIG205DP Pro. This listing ranks at the top for range and control: 8 welding modes, 205A output, 120V/240V dual voltage, a full-color LCD screen, app control, and 159 built-in parameter presets with SYN and manual modes. The package includes a MIG torch, ground clamp, electrode holder, gas hose and regulator. Protection includes dual cooling fans, VRD technology, and protection against overcurrent, overvoltage, overload and overheating. The listing states 3-year quality and expert technical service, the longest stated service term in this guide.

ANDELI MIG-205DP. This listing ranks next as the only machine here that cuts as well as welds: 8 in 1 multi-function operation with Pulsed MIG, Gas MIG, SYN/MAN MIG, HF TIG, CUT, Clean, Cold, Spot Welding and MMA, with 205A max welding current and 50A max cutting current. It uses 110V/220V dual-voltage auto-detection, and states Clean Cut 10mm (3/8″) and Maximum Cut 18mm (2/3″). It is CE certified with auto shut-off protection and over-heat protection, and the listing states a 2-year warranty with free replacement parts. The package includes a TIG torch and a plasma cutting torch.

BILT HARD 250A. This listing ranks next on output: up to 250A, 110V/220V dual voltage, 6 functions, and it can weld up to a 3/8″ plate. The synergic system adjusts voltage and feed speed based on amperage, and the listing states a large LED display, burn-back and inductance adjustment in MIG mode, hot start, arc force, VRD and anti-stick in MMA mode, and a 60% duty cycle at 250A. Protection includes overheat and overcurrent protection. Two points hold it back: the TIG gun and spool gun are not included, and the listing states no concrete warranty term, only that the maker stands behind the welder.

haxiaoer 250Amp stick welder. This listing ranks last as the simplest machine here and the clearest pick for electrode-only work: a 250Amp stick-only machine for 110V household supply, with hot start, adjustable arc force and anti-stick, support for 1/16 inch to 1/8 inch electrodes such as E6013, E6011, E7018 and E308, and automatic shutdown on over-voltage, over-current, overheat and overload, plus a high-speed cooling fan. The listing describes a compact body that stores in a backpack or toolbox, and states no dimensions, no weight and no warranty term. It covers the narrowest range of jobs in this guide, and that is the trade for its simplicity.

How to choose between stick and multiprocess

• Match the process list to the work. Electrode-only work points to the stick machine; MIG, TIG, spot or plasma work points to a multiprocess listing.
• Check the power supply. A 110V household supply runs the stick-only machine. The ARCCAPTAIN listing states light DIY runs on 110V/120V household outlets while a 220V/240V supply unleashes its full 205A power, so check what each multiprocess listing states for full output. For a 220V/240V circuit, have a licensed electrician check the circuit and follow the manual.
• Check what is in the box. BILT HARD notes the TIG gun and spool gun are not included, ARCCAPTAIN notes the TIG torch and spool gun are sold separately, and ANDELI includes a TIG torch and a plasma cutting torch.
• Compare the stated protections. VRD, overheat, overcurrent, overvoltage and overload protection appear in different combinations across these listings, and ANDELI adds CE certification.
• Read the warranty term. ARCCAPTAIN states 3-year quality service, ANDELI states a 2-year warranty, and BILT HARD and haxiaoer state no concrete term.

FAQ: garage tools

Can a multiprocess welder replace a stick welder?

Yes, for electrode work: every multiprocess listing here includes stick welding among its modes. BILT HARD lists Stick among 6 functions, ARCCAPTAIN lists Stick Welding among 8 modes, and ANDELI lists MMA. A multiprocess machine still needs the right electrodes and settings for the rod in hand.

Do multiprocess welders need gas for every process?

No. Gas MIG needs shielding gas, but Gasless Flux Core MIG runs without it, and stick welding uses flux-coated electrodes. The ARCCAPTAIN and BILT HARD listings both list Gasless Flux Core MIG as a mode.

What power supply does a garage welder need?

It depends on the listing. The haxiaoer stick machine runs on 110V household supply. The multiprocess listings use dual voltage: 110V/220V for BILT HARD and ANDELI, and 120V/240V for ARCCAPTAIN. For a 220V/240V circuit, have a licensed electrician check the circuit.

Is a plasma cutter the same as a welder?

No. A plasma cutter cuts metal with a pilot arc, while a welder joins it. The ANDELI combo does both, with 50A max cutting current, Clean Cut 10mm (3/8″) and Maximum Cut 18mm (2/3″).

What electrodes does a stick welder use?

The haxiaoer listing supports 1/16 inch to 1/8 inch electrodes such as E6013, E6011, E7018 and E308, for mild steel, cast iron and stainless steel.

Which machine suits thin sheet metal?

The ARCCAPTAIN listing says single pulse handles thin sheet metal repair without burn-through, and the ANDELI listing describes a COLD welding mode with a low-heat advantage on thin stainless and carbon steel. Check the manual for the thickness range of each mode.

Related: stick welder vs plasma cutter, the best welding cart for a home garage, flux-core welders for hobbyists and welding goggles vs welding helmet.